Wednesday, March 11, 2009

UNSOLICITED OPINION ON NAMES
I don't know why I was thinking about this today. But it's a little pet peeve of mine. I know this topic can be rather charged with emotion, so as a disclaimer, I don't want to start a debate and I'm sorry if I ruffle up some feathers. This is just my opinion.

Here's what I think is happening. Girls are stealing all the boys' names. They have been doing it for a long time. So boys have had to resort to being named a surname, like Carter and Hanson.

I have met or know of men named Shannon, Kelly, Kim, Ashley, and Courtney. The names Tracy, Stacy, and Allison were also men's names. Then there's Gayle, Evelyn, Leslie, Marion, Vivian, Beverly, Dana, Carol, Whitney, Kimberly, Sidney, Jodi, and Tiffany. If you were to read these names in a list, you'd probably think they're all women.

There are lots of names in transition right now. Think about all the Taylors and Jordans you know. How many are girls and how many are boys? It's sort of 50-50 now, but I think it's leaning in the female direction.

Then there are a few that I'm not sure of, like Kendall. That sure sounds like a boys' name. You know, Ken? I've never heard of a girl named Ken, but that's the obvious nickname for Kendall.

And then there are the more trendy girl names like Ashton and Peyton and Grayson. Ashton Kutcher is a man, and Peyton Manning is a freakin' huge football player! Despite Allison being a very much accepted girls' name, I don't think I can ever name a girl anything that ends in "son." Because Grayson really means, "the son of Gray." Maybe Gray Davis? I mean Joe Davis? (former Governor of CA who did a poll and found that if he changed his name to Gray, he'd get more votes.)

Really, are there not enough names for girls? They're going to take them ALL!!! It's not like they're not making up new ones for girls, too. I had never heard of a Brinley or Kaylie 5 years ago, but there are lots and lots of them now. So why take boy names?

Here's another thought. As I was searching for more boy-names-now-turned-girly names online, I found this quote:
"Yeah and what about the boys who have names that were boys names when they were born but now their name is a girl name. That could screw with your head..."

I always wanted a little boy named Ryan. I got a big one instead :) But now the girls are stealing that one, too. Once we went out to eat and the waiter, busboy, and hostess were all named Ryan.

I may be spreading rumors, but I remember the boom in girls named Ryan came after a soap opera named one of its female characters Ryan. My research (however unreliable) says that Courtney became a girls' name when a female protaganist in a trashy novel hit bookstands in the 50's. Hip hip hooray, we're naming our kids after trashy books and tv shows!

There are names that go for both genders, like Terry, but they're not super popular at this point in time. And there are other names that have the same nickname, like Samuel and Samantha. And then there are the ones that sound the same but are spelled differently, like Aaron and Erin. At least with these, the girls aren't stealing the name so boys can't use them anymore!

I've got to say that I love the name Kelly for a girl. Probably because I have a sister with that name. But I still feel bad for all the men named Kelly who had their name girlified.

And just when you thought that you'd heard it all, I've caught wind of girls named Bruce, Jeremy, and Richard.

If you have an opinion you'd like to share in comments, please do, but keep it nice. I think I did!

7 comments:

Emily said...

My husband and I have had many conversations about kids' names!
I totally see where you are coming from though.
Here is my opinion: I think it's ok to use the boy names that are turning into girls name AS LONG AS it is a becoming a common girls name (the trendy ones you talked about)...for example: Jordan, Taylor, Ashton, Peyton, etc. I have to say that because we HAVE a girl named Jordyn! haha. And that is EXACTLY why we spelled it with a "Y"... so people would know it's a girl. It actually works most of the time. We do get the occasionally person on the phone who thinks she's a boy. I also thought if I had another girl that Taylor would be cute to go along with Jordyn...but I could see how that may make it even more confusing. We even considered Peyton for a BOY, but decided against it since it's becoming a popular girl's name.
BUT, I think the names that really are "girl" names (Tracy, Stacy, Gayle, Tiffany, Evelyn..etc) should stay girl names forever! I can't even IMAGINE seeing a man with that name!
So I have no idea, I may be contradicting myself! I guess I'm ok with the trendy names or names in transition....just not the really ODD boy/girl names.
And just for kicks(this is probably a whole diff. post!) we have distant family members who named their daughter - Denim Blue - and named their son - Blazin Trails. True Story!

CB said...

I totally think you are right. I have a boy named Ryan and a boy named Taylor. When they were born those were totally boy names.

I don't run into too many girl Ryan's but Taylor has really taken off as a girl name also. I have a friend with a little girl named Tayler spelled with an er - a little more girly.

Courtney I have never known as anything else but a girl name so that is interesting.

Erin said...

I have to confess... I'm one of those who liks boyish hames for girls... Hence, Kenley. Its slightly boyish. (And, its a last name, which seems to be a trend in naming as well - Last names.)
I read a book when I was a kid with a female character named Jeremy (maybe a Judy Blume book... if not her, someone like her) and I love Michael (Mykel) for a girl... I think we should maybe just start viewing all names as unisex. All names can work for all babies... (To prove it, I'll name my first boy Susie.)

Susie said...

Oh no you don't, Erin. A boy named Sue should be restricted only to that song and/or pets!
I would have been okay with your girl cat being named Gary, too.

I agree, it's too late to go back on most of these "transgendered" names, but let's not make any more!!! I don't want Jared (mabye Jaryd?) and Zachary (maybe Zachyry?) to be girls names!!!

As far as a lot of names, like Jordan and Taylor and Payton/Peyton, they weren't really either gender at one time. Not Ryan, Jeremy, and Richard! So those are kind of difficult to sort out for me. I think I'll just steer clear!

Anonymous said...

I've met a male Shannon and a female Kevin. When I went to Europe the summer I turned 9 the people kept asking my mom why she gave me a boy's name! (For clarification: one 'e' is male and two 'e's is female. I do get really annoyed when Americans botch my name and basically make me a boy on paper).

Matt got his nickname from 'Masterson'. And speaking of last names for names: Anderson Cooper on CNN. I kinda like it and Jackson.

But I agree, the whole transgender/trendy names get to be too much. And just to add to Emily's story, while I was at the Doctor's with Alex there was a little girl named 'Sincere'.

Huh?? That's a name??

Lil Lancaster Fam said...

I love old fashioned girl names, Anna, Emma, if I have another girl Jane. Brynlee was a name on my girl list along with Britley(have a cousin with that one). I also like boy names for girls, such as Ryan, Johnnie, my name is a version being Erin. But the backing of this is because of name sake. Johnnie is a long time family name. For girls in my fam. There are also a lot of the boy version being John. People like to name there children after relatives. So if a family has girls they start naming them after Grandpa John. So my grandmother is Frances Johnnie. Growing up I always thought I would name a girl Ryan after my brother. Jeremy Ryan. Anyways I think names should have some kind of meaning to you or if you just want something different go with Denim Blue, that cracks me up. I really hate picking out names it is always so hard for me to decide on the right name for that baby. It is what they will be called for their entire life. More importantly it is what you have to say about a billion times a day! So I always test it out by saying, "Kaleb" don't do that, or "fill in the blank" don't hit your sister. or "..." stop jumping on the bed. Anyways you get the idea.

Oh and I agree keep the only boy Sue to the one in the song!;)

Kat said...

I do have to say that I had NEVER heard of Brinley except for 1 little girl that we named our little Brinley after. And now, they are POPPING out of the woodwork. Seriously, can't I have one name that isn't like everyone else? I do have to say that I did have the name RyAnn picked out for a girls name ever since high school cause I liked the originality of it. However, when we moved here, there was a little girl named Ryan in our ward and I decided to never do it. Oh, and I never watched soup operas. So, it couldn't of influenced me. :) I thought I was being original.